Fifth in a series: Five disruptive church trends in 2025.
April 30, 2025
By Rev. Rick King
Carey Nieuwhof is the Canadian pastor and trend-spotter I read who annually publishes a list of “disruptive church trends” that he believes will affect churches of all types, even though he writes with a primarily evangelical audience in mind. I’m interested in how we can view this year’s five disruptive trends through the lens of our merger process. Each week, we’ll look at a different trend and see how it applies to us as we try to plant a new church out of a merger of two existing churches facing challenges. Source of the content is Nieuwhof’s blog, but the take on it is my own.
There was a lot of talk in clergy circles during the pandemic about clergy mental health.
During 2020-21, I so looked forward to the weekly Minnesota Conference UCC clergy support calls on Zoom. We shared what was going on in our churches and households, the struggles and victories and what we found helpful in coping with the stress and isolation of COVID.
Clergy mental health has rebounded somewhat from those days. And although the number of ministers who have experienced the impulse to quit full-time ministry has dropped from 42 percent in 2022 to 33 percent in 2023, according to Barna Group, a third of all U.S. pastors still think seriously of leaving ministry.
And get this: 18 percent of pastors have thought about suicide or self-harm in the past year, fueled by loneliness and isolation among lead pastors that is intensifying, not declining.
There’s been a precipitous drop in pastors who say they regularly get the personal support they need to thrive in their field, from 37 percent to 19 percent over the past 10 years! That means 81 percent are NOT getting regular support.
Personally, I’ve worked hard over 35 years of ministry to ensure I have the support I need. And while 21 percent of clergy over the age of 45 say they’re flourishing in their well-being, under the age of 45 only 7 percent say that.
Why does this matter to us, as we move toward a merger? Because the next generation of church leaders is not okay. Not only is there a leader shortage in the church, but those leaders of the next generation aren’t thriving.
Since the new church birthed by our possible merger with New Life will likely be looking for a next generation pastoral leader, this crisis will affect our church directly in the next few years. Economic challenges, global instability, and other factors will push church leaders in ways they’ve never been pushed.
People watching this trend in alarm admit there’s no “fix” for this generational mental health crisis. But as Easter people, we believe that God can bring life-giving wisdom out of death-dealing circumstances. We need to be looking for the new things God can do in the life of our churches and their leaders. Nieuwhof proposes a few:
It comes from the top – Senior leaders of churches can have a positive impact by modeling healthy practices and balanced lives, both in leadership and in their personal lives. Not only regularly taking time off, but cultivating healthy practices for mind, body, soul and spirit to be renewed. No one else can decide to do this, but churches can encourage leaders to do this and fund it in their budgets. Not to do so is short-sighted and a recipe for burnout.
Think of the team – Paid staff in churches need to be encouraged to practice healthy, balanced living, but so do lay leaders. Checking in with each other regularly has been important as our lay leaders go through life crises and other changes in their lives, as well as making sure we share the load with each other and regularly ask each other for help. The mission of the institution is never more important than caring for people.
Live today so you thrive tomorrow – Not survive, but thrive. And that goes for the church, not just the pastor.
What are YOUR thoughts about this? What are YOU seeing and hearing from friends in other churches?